Shady emails and comments about Sergio Rivera-Ayala’s new book, El discurso colonial en textos novohispanos: espacio, cuerpo y poder
Sun 27 Sep 2009, 10:35 pm
Update 7 Oct 2009: Professor Rivera-Ayala responded to my email and I posted our exchange.
This is the kind of thing I can’t stand.
A senior student sent Iris Jastram at Pegasus Librarian an email suggesting that she buy Sergio Rivera-Ayala’s new book, El discurso colonial en textos novohispanos: espacio, cuerpo y poder. That’s a pretty normal thing for librarians at institutions like Iris’s and mine. I tell students working on theses to let me know if they come across books we should own.
But this email was strange enough to ring some warning bells for Iris. She tends to know the seniors in her subject areas, and they call their senior projects “comps,” not “thesis.” So she called the registrar and found no student by that name registered.
So the message was spam. Sleezy spam. From the publisher, Tamesis? From the author Sergio Rivera-Ayala? It’s impossible to tell, and Iris is wise enough not to speculate.
So that was a little kerfuffle, but it cooled right down. Until the comments tonight.
Someone using the name “Verga Parati” makes a comment wondering why she wouldn’t just buy the book anyway. I mean, besides the lying fraud, it’s probably a good book anyway? The commenter ends with “Jesus, what kind of librarians are you?”
I wondered what kind of commenter this was, so I googled the name to find out that “verga para ti” is Spanish for “cock for you.” Boy, I’d hate my parents if they somehow accidentally gave me a name that was a Spanish obscenity. Then every time I showed up in someone’s blog comments to give them a hard time about not adding a Spanish-language book to the collection, they wouldn’t take me seriously and would assume I was trying to send a veiled sexually hostile message to the librarian. Man, that would be a drag.
Then another comment comment from Mr./Ms Cock came in, trying to be a little nicer, but still implying that Iris should buy the book. Iris’s last reply makes it clear that she knows where the cock person is posting from and that this information is perhaps incriminating to some degree.
I’m sorry that this post is mostly a play-by-play rehash of something on Pegasus Librarian. But this is the kind of thing I simply hate: people using the anonymity of the net to try and lie and defraud and intimidate. I’ll be contacting the author, Sergio Rivera-Ayala, and the publisher, Tamesis, tomorrow to be sure they know that someone is doing this. If I were Sergio Rivera-Ayala, I’d be most distressed that someone was griefing librarians about my book and I would make every effort to find the real emailer and commenter and make them apologize publicly.
(This also reminds me that I need to make a comment policy. Basically, anyone who uses a pseudonym or otherwise falsely identifies themselves in my comments gives up all right to privacy. Try and pull any crap like this with me and I will publish your IP address and everything I know about you.)

Agreed, agreed, agreed. Communications that would have been completely unacceptable in a pen-and-paper environment have somehow become commonplace, and it’s just not okay.
Comment by Jenica Rogers-Urbanek — September 28, 2009 @ 9:37 am
My name is Steve and I publish this blog. Who are you to tell me how to comment?
Oh, and please don’t publish everything you know about me… that would take far to long…
-Steve
:-)’
Comment by Aaron the Librarian — September 28, 2009 @ 10:22 am
ALA Council Member, Aaron Dobbs, ladies and gentlemen. (I can’t think of anything more incriminating than that!)
Comment by Steve Lawson — September 28, 2009 @ 10:31 am
We’ve gotten requests supposedly from faculty members on our request form. (Someone says they are Prof. YYY requesting book ZZZ). We can often spot the fake request, since the comments about why we need to book are a little “off kilter”. We take all requests with a grain of salt, no matter who the requester is.
Comment by Joe Kraus — September 30, 2009 @ 1:04 pm
This is happening at public libraries as well. All of a sudden I have been getting “requests” from “patrons” to buy books that don’t seem to actually exist (?) or are of questionable “quality.” Then our consortium sent out an email saying that this was happening all over the area.
As for the “legitimate” marketing that is being done by self-published or small-press-published authors who are merely trying to sell their work, well, I’m not sure what to think of that. I mean, yes, it is SPAM, but isn’t most advertising? Every once in a while I find something worth buying….
Comment by Jessica — October 3, 2009 @ 10:44 pm
[...] Ah, what fun. I got an email today from Dr. Rivera-Ayala that was cc’d to my Dean and the President of my college. I thought you’d like to see the exchange, starting with the email I sent to Sergio Rivera-Ayala after my last post about the strange emails and comments about his book. [...]
Pingback by See Also… » Email from Sergio Rivera-Ayala about the spam and blog comments promoting his book — October 7, 2009 @ 11:25 am
While I agree that pretending to be a student isn’t the best strategy, it shows how desperate more and more authors are finding it hard to be read or just available on shelves and feeling pressure from publishers to do their bit. As an another with her first scholarly book out, I have reached out to libraries because I don’t have the advantage of fiction/trendy subjects.
That said: nothing means you can insult someone’s profession or blog topics. After all what else is free media exchange about?
Comment by Mohadoha — October 9, 2009 @ 6:37 am
[...] you are wondering why this is funny, see this post and this other [...]
Pingback by See Also… » Outflanked — November 25, 2009 @ 1:44 pm
[...] then the comments on that post got really interesting really fast? And remember when Steve Lawson shed a little light on the less savory aspects of those comments? And then remember when Steve later got unpleasant [...]
Pingback by Sergio Rivera-Ayala’s Book Strikes (out) Again — January 14, 2010 @ 11:51 am
[...] about Sergio Rivera-Ayala and the odd emails and blog comments that Iris Jastram received (see Shady emails and comments about Sergio Rivera-Ayala’s new book, El discurso colonial en textos nov… and Email from Sergio Rivera-Ayala about the spam and blog comments promoting his book) I held back [...]
Pingback by See Also… » What I hope will be the last thing I ever have to post about Sergio Rivera-Ayala — January 15, 2010 @ 1:08 pm